I should totally be headed to bed right now, but this topic is on my mind and sort of refuses to geroff. I can only hope to dislodge it through writing.
Here's the thing: As I may have mentioned before, I belong to a comics-themed yahoo list, and one of the members recently posted a friendly survey which included the question 'Who is your favorite female comic book character?' For the first couple of days after his post, I had every intention of finding time to fill out the survey myself. But I just could not get past this question.
I not only know my favorite male comic book character, I can *effortlessly* produce my top five. I mean, they come to me immediately, in priority order. (Nightwing, Alfred, the new Blue Beetle, Batman, Dr. Mid-Nite. Done). With the possible exception of Batman, all these male characters are individuals with whom I
identify - and in a variety of ways. But I can't think of a single female with whom I equally identify and whom I can comfortably call my favorite female comic book character.
Now, for the record, I acknowledge all of the following as true:
- I do not read anything like all or most of the comic books available - not even all or most of the good ones. So I have very limited credibility. There are probably awesome characters I would love if only I knew about them.
- Comic books are not traditionally great places to go looking for well-rounded female characters. I should probably know better than to try, especially so long as it continues to be true that publishers want female fans but lose patience with the very characters and kinds of stories that turn out to be popular with women. (It's kind of disgusting that 'lots of women like X' is so often taken to be a bad sign).
- There are at least a few strong female characters in comics of whom I am aware. Barbara Gordon, presently a.k.a Oracle, probably should place as my favorite by default, since she's complex and female and I think she's been written well over the years. But I don't identify with her. Personality-wise, we almost could not be more opposite. (For uninitiates, imagine a female Batman and you're 85% there, imho). I'd kind of like my very favorite female character to be one for whom I feel a deep personal affection, one who reminds me at least a little of myself - not merely An Example of a Good Female Character or even just a character whose added presence significantly enhances stories I enjoy. I could say much the same thing about Lois Lane or Catwoman. Really neat characters; just not for me. (On a near-irrelevant note for those to whom this will mean anything: I also have a preemptive soft spot for Big Barda, though I've read next to nothing about her. If I read about Big Barda, I bet I would like Big Barda).
- There are female characters in comics who do resemble me in some way but who bore me. I'm kind of like Nightwing's sweet gal pal, Donna Troy, but once you get past her notoriously torrid and incomprehensible origin story, there's not a lot to her from what I've seen. (Though she does have the aforementioned function of enhancing stories I enjoy reading by virtue of being present).
- There are female characters I once liked very much and with whom I
did identify in the way I have in mind - at one time - but who have since been utterly bent out of shape for the sake of shock value or ever-increasing emphasis on badassery. (Leslie Thompkins and poor Cassandra Cain are great examples from this category, for those keeping score. It's hard for me not to feel a conviction that both characters have been spoiled past rehabilitation. And it's probably weird to say that someone is your favorite when you can't really even stand her anymore).
That part took longer than I meant it to. I must get to the point!
Already badly troubled by my inability to think of a well-developed female comic book character whom I relate to in the same way I relate to the males (maybe Blue Beetle's mom? I'm serious; she might be as close as I get), I went on to mentally work out my meme-list of favorite characters from favorite books and movies and whatnot.
And at the risk of giving away all my incredibly-hard-to-guess answers to the meme (haha), the vast majority of my favorite characters are MALE. Moreover, they are usually males who act as the emotional core of their stories. They are soft-hearted, even sentimental (I hate the whole thing where we automatically call men of feeling and reflection 'emo' now) fellows in whom I am apparently far more likely to see myself than in their female counterparts (presuming, of course, that there are any female counterparts around with whom to compare them).
Now, once again, all the following are true:
-There are more male characters.
-There are more well-rounded male characters.
-There are more male protagonists.
-There are more male POV characters.
-There are more funny male characters.
-There are more prominent male writers, who are probably more apt at endowing their male characters with sympathetic traits, simply by virtue of their greater experience of being male than female.
-Ever-so-many female characters are mainly present in their stories as love-interests, meant to signal to you that the male protagonist is a Person of Consequence (since he can attract him some pretty ladies), and/or to be awarded to the male protagonist following whatever major accomplishment or breakthrough amounts to the climax of the story. (Does anybody really prefer Lucie Manette to Charles or Sydney? No? Not even when she's so pretty and devoted and good at interior decorating on a budget?)
With all those male characters running around out there, it's no wonder I end up really, really liking a fair few of them. (Also, we should probably factor in all of the hormones I have running around on the
inside. I am attracted to men, and I like characters to whom I am attracted. *cough* Kestrel *cough*).
Now, there are totally aspects of the broader human experience that can come home to me with depth and poignancy when embodied by male characters. Without question. It's not the fact that I so often identify with well-written male characters that I find troubling or mystifying. It's the fact that when I think about the well-written or stand-out female characters, I mostly
don't especially identify with them. Quoth Miss Clavelle, 'Something is not right!'
Which brings me to the question that originally motivated this post: what do we
mean when we ask for 'strong female characters'? Because what I mostly mean is 'Female characters who are treated as multi-faceted persons of consequence.' But when it comes time to say more about what kinds of women and girls will make the cut, I tend to start hearing words like 'tough,' 'plucky,' 'snarky,' 'take-no-prisoners,' 'fierce,' 'outspoken,' 'badass,' blah blah blah. Then there's another class of 'strong' female characters: the subsidiary group who may not be physically tough or, I dunno, intrepid, unsinkable super-sleuths or whatever, but who come across as 'strong' in part because they are remarkably rational, cool, or emotionally distant/illiterate.
It's hard for me to think of very many well-rounded (or otherwise notable) female characters, especially from popular culture, who aren't 'strong' in something like the above respects.
Now watch as I play the 'list a bunch of things I think are true' game one final time:
-It's only natural for us to find the boldest, most dynamic characters especially exciting. Especially decisive and resilient people make for some of the best, most engaging heroes.
-There totally should be plucky, smart, resourceful woman and girl heroines. There totally should be emotionally distant, inarticulate, and reckless female heroines. I personally enjoy such characters, to a point.
- It is also true that I AM NOT LIKE THAT. I am not Elizabeth Bennet. I am not Buffy the Vampire Slayer (maybe Willow). I am not Starbuck. I am not Lara Croft, Tomb Raider. I am not Wonder Woman. I am no kind of fast-talking, charismatic diva. (Well, I do talk fast...) I am not a district attorney or a surgeon or a detective or a cop, and I don't think I ever could be. I am not particularly resilient, bold, loud, resourceful or cool under pressure. I have never confessed to a priest that my primary character flaw was anything like 'simply too wild a heart!'
I tend toward the passive and the sentimental. I hesitate to rival Hamlet. I'm a nurturer and a people pleaser. I'm socially awkward, introverted, and much better at playing defense than offense. I'm a
dependent rational animal. Where are the 'strong' women who feel like me to me?* I don't think being like me rules out being a strong woman (though I do hesitate to say I'd read a book or watch a tv show about me...). But it is clearly not the case that persons with my weaknesses make automatically poor characters. 'Cause we apparently allow - and take interest in - such faults when the characters are
male.**
Nightwing, with his irritating sense of humor and overly conscientious habit of taking everything to heart, feels like me to me. Blue Beetle, with his uncertainty about his place in the world, feels like me to me. Alfred, dearest of ennablers, feels like me to me. Lee Adama, with his awkward inwardness and feet of clay, feels like me to me. Dorky Chuck Bartowski, who prefers *not* to be shot at, feels like me to me. Sebastian Flyte feels like me to a point that I find frankly terrifying. One does not like to see one's guts spilled out on the page for all to see.
It would probably not be good for the world if the few female characters there
are weren't notably plucky and bright and brave and resourceful and badass. Perpetuating female stereotypes and all that. But the fact that my personality accords with certain female stereotypes speaks, in my opinion, not to the essential inferiority of that personality, but to a misguided view that stereotypically masculine traits (boldness, pride, aggressiveness, emotional distance) are the traits that pick out a strong, worthwhile, interesting person. Especially after years and years surrounded by mostly men - and philosophers, at that, pleh - I am definitely an 'it takes all kinds' sort of girl. And as much as I want to discipline myself out of some very serious personal weaknesses, I don't think I need to do it by reinventing myself as a paradigm ass-kicker. Or as a man, for that matter. I intend to stay very much myself - tendency toward passivity and all.
So for anyone who has read all this (and it's really late, so it's entirely possible that the foregoing makes next to no sense; we'll see in the morning...) this is what I want to know:
What do you require in a 'strong' female character? What traits do you personally value in the characters whom you find especially sympathetic? Do you also tend to be more drawn to characters of the opposite sex? Can you think of any really fabulous (but not especially badass) female characters to cheer me up?
*The blind, unbalanced level of affection I have for a certain smattering of atypical female characters begins to make that much more sense to me...
**As tempestsarekind aptly pointed out earlier today (er, yesterday), this totally doesn't mean that emotional male characters don't take a lot of abuse or get called wusses and junk. But they exist. And they don't generally have to make up for their emotional existence by fulfilling the thankless role of damsel in distress.